Donor retention: How commercial loyalty thinking helps nonprofits earn the second gift

Donor retention: How commercial loyalty thinking helps nonprofits earn the second gift

DHM Team
16 November 2026
Company employees working in software development and designer office
Company business employees working in software development and designer office
Company employees working in software development and designer office
Company business employees working in software development and designer office

Donor retention: How commercial loyalty thinking helps nonprofits earn the second gift

DHM Team
16 November 2026

Nonprofits can lift donor retention by treating the second gift the way commercial brands treat a repeat purchase. That means naming the behaviour you want, recognising supporters in ways that matter to them and acting early when engagement slows. 

The share of taxpayers claiming a tax-deductible donation fell from 35.1% in 2013–14 to 27.8% in 2022–23 (The Conversation, 2025), and ATO figures for 2023–24 show it holding at around 28% (ATO, 2026). With fewer Australians claiming gifts than a decade ago, keeping each supporter is a priority for every fundraising team.

Why is the second gift so important for donor retention?

In our playbook, Designing loyalty to unlock growth, we describe a loyal customer as someone who chooses you repeatedly, recommends you without being asked and stays when a cheaper or easier option exists. Donor loyalty works the same way. A first gift shows interest, and a second gift shows a relationship forming.

Dataro’s analysis of more than 300 nonprofits found that around 28% of new donors gave a second gift in 2023. Once a donor gives twice, 59% keep giving. Recurring donors are retained at 83%, compared with 45% for single-gift donors, and they’re worth 5.4 times as much over their lifetime (Dataro). In Australia and New Zealand, the average donor’s lifetime value rises from $900 at year five to $2,340 at year ten.

These figures show where to focus. Earning the second gift, and then the move to regular giving, does more for long-term income than another wave of first-time donors.

What motivates donor loyalty?

Commercial loyalty programs balance two kinds of reward. Discounts and points lower the cost of staying, while recognition, access and belonging raise the value of the relationship. Donors sit almost entirely on the second side. They give because helping a cause they care about feels good, and every thank-you, impact update and personal touch adds to that feeling. 

What donors want in return is proof that their gift made a difference, recognition that feels personal and a sense of belonging to a cause they care about. Practical details still count. Easy giving, flexible payment options and tax receipts that arrive on time remove friction, and the emotional rewards give supporters their reason to stay.

Five commercial loyalty principles that work for nonprofits

  1. Decide how you’ll measure success:
    Commercial brands track share of wallet: how much of a customer’s spending in a category comes to them. For a nonprofit, it’s the share of a supporter’s giving that goes to your cause. You can’t see what supporters give elsewhere, but a short supporter survey gives you an estimate, and a rising share shows your cause moving up their list. Agree on this measure, and the others in the metrics section below, before you design anything, so you know what a good result looks like. 

  2. Name the behaviour you want:
    The first question in our playbook asks what behaviour a program should change or reinforce. For a nonprofit, that might be a second gift within 90 days, a move from one-off to monthly giving, an upgrade, a first volunteer shift or a gift in a will. Each behaviour calls for its own journey, and naming it tells you exactly what to measure.

  3. Choose visible or silent recognition:
    A visible approach uses a named giving circle or supporter tiers, so donors can see their place in your community. A silent approach recognises people in the background, such as a personal thank-you call from your CEO after a donor’s third gift. Some supporters enjoy public recognition and others prefer a quiet thank you, and offering both lets each donor choose.

  4. Re-engage early:
    Retailers watch for customers whose visits are slowing. Nonprofits can watch for a regular gift that doesn’t go through, a donor whose usual giving month has passed, emails that haven’t been opened or clicked for a while, or a volunteer who hasn’t signed up for the next event. Each moment is a chance to reach out with something personal, such as an update on the program their last gift funded.

  5. Launch narrow and learn:
    Our golden rule for loyalty design is to start simple, start early and keep learning. For nonprofits, a natural starting point is first-time donors in their first 90 days. Focusing on that one group and one goal, the second gift, gives you clean data and a result your board can see.

How does connected data improve donor retention?

Supporters wear several hats. The same person might give monthly, run in your fun run, volunteer at events and share your campaigns with friends. Seeing all of that in one place shows your team the full relationship and helps every message feel connected.

In Salesforce, Nonprofit Cloud or the Nonprofit Success Pack (NPSP) holds the donor record, Data 360 brings giving, event, volunteer and email data together into one supporter profile, and Marketing Cloud Next turns that profile into stewardship journeys. Fundraisers can build segments themselves with drag and drop tools, such as event participants who haven’t yet made a direct gift, without waiting on IT. Predictive models can then help your team spot donors who are ready for regular giving or whose engagement is slowing, so you can reach them at the right moment.

Which metrics measure donor loyalty?

Total donors and total income show how far your fundraising reaches. To see whether supporters are staying, track these measures alongside them:

  • Second-gift rate for new donors
  • Overall donor retention rate
  • Conversion from one-off to regular giving
  • Upgrade rate among regular givers
  • Supporter lifetime value
  • Reactivation of lapsed donors

Each measure points to a specific journey you can improve, which makes it easy to decide where your next investment goes.

Donor retention FAQs

What is a good donor retention rate?
Overall donor retention of around 45% to 57% is in line with current benchmarks. Dataro reported global retention of 57.1% in 2023, and North American benchmarks sit between 40% and 50%. For new donors, a second-gift rate above 28% puts you ahead of the average.

How do you calculate donor retention rate?
Divide the number of donors who gave in both this year and last year by the total number of donors from last year, then multiply by 100. If 400 of last year’s 1,000 donors gave again, your retention rate is 40%.

How can nonprofits improve donor retention?
Nonprofits improve donor retention by focusing on the first 90 days after a first gift, showing donors their impact, recognising them personally and inviting them into regular giving. Acting early when a regular gift fails or engagement slows also helps keep supporters giving.

What is the difference between donor retention and donor loyalty?
Donor retention measures whether a supporter gives again within a set period. Donor loyalty describes the relationship behind that gift, including how connected a supporter feels, whether they recommend your cause and whether they stay involved through volunteering, events or advocacy.

InsightsRecent Articles